Elegoo Phecda 10WvsLonger Ray5 20WvsMecpow X3 Pro 10WvsAcmer P1 S Pro 20WvsOMTech K40 Plus

Longer Ray5 20W
Longer Ray5 20W
Longer
OMTech K40 Plus
OMTech K40 Plus
Omtech
Laser modules
Diode(OpenFrame)
455 nm · 10 W
Diode(OpenFrame)
455 nm · 20 W
Diode(OpenFrame)
455 nm · 10 W
Diode(OpenFrame)
455 nm · 20 W
CO2(Desktop)
10640 nm · 40 W
Work area
400 mm400 mm
🥇Elegoo Phecda 10W
400 × 400 mm
375 mm375 mm
🥉Longer Ray5 20W
375 × 375 mm
400 mm400 mm
🥈Mecpow X3 Pro 10W
400 × 400 mm
380 mm350 mm
Acmer P1 S Pro 20W
380 × 350 mm
300 mm200 mm
OMTech K40 Plus
300 × 200 mm
Z height
190 mm47 mm55 mm
Speed
417 mm/s167 mm/s166 mm/s167 mm/s300 mm/s
Best price
$195.00Elegoo ShopView offer
Elegoo Shop (United States)
$379.99Longer ShopView offer
Longer Shop (International)
$289.99Mecpow ShopView offer
Mecpow Shop (International)
$329.00Acmer ShopView offer
Acmer Shop (International)
$799.99Omtech ShopView offer
Omtech Shop (United States)
Connection type
SD-CardSD-CARDUSBUSBWIFIWIFI
WIFIWIFIUSBUSBSD-CardSD-CARD
USBUSBWIFIWIFI
WIFIWIFIUSBUSBSD-CardSD-CARD
USBUSB
Air Assist
Camera
Enclosure
Autofocus
Software
Operating systems
WindowsmacOSLinux
WindowsmacOSiOSiPadOSAndroid
WindowsmacOSLinuxiOSiPadOSAndroid
WindowsmacOSLinux
File formats
.ai.svg.dxf.pdf.hpgl.plt.rd.png.jpeg.bmp.tiff.tga.gif.jpg
.svg.dxf.jpg.png.bmp
.ai.svg.dxf.pdf.hpgl.plt.rd.png.jpeg.bmp.tiff.tga.gif.jpg
.ai.svg.dxf.pdf.hpgl.plt.rd.png.jpeg.bmp.tiff.tga.gif.jpg
Laser class
Class 4Class 4Class 4Class 4Class 1
Weight
6.5 kg5.5 kg3.67 kg3.6 kg23 kg
Warranty
12 months12 months12 months12 months24 months
Release
April 8, 2023December 12, 2022June 1, 2023July 3, 2023August 15, 2022
Price/performance
9/10
8/10
8/10
9/10
9/10
Technical parameters
7/10
7/10
7/10
7/10
7/10
User-friendliness
6/10
6/10
6/10
8/10
6/10
Customer service
8/10
7/10
7/10
6/10
5/10
PROS
  • Aggressive price point
  • Large 400x400mm work area
  • Sturdy aluminum alloy frame
  • Finer laser spot for detailed engraving
  • Compatible with LightBurn and LaserGRBL
  • Powerful 20W laser for the price
  • Can cut thick materials like 15mm pine in one pass
  • Multi-color engraving on stainless steel
  • Multiple connectivity options (USB, Wi-Fi, SD card)
  • Offline control via 3.5-inch touchscreen
  • Bundled adjustable air assist
  • Comprehensive safety features (limit switches, tilt sensor)
  • Good engraving precision
  • Affordable price point
  • Compatible with LightBurn and LaserGRBL
  • Excellent value for money
  • Exceptionally rigid all-metal frame for its class
  • Features limit switches on both axes
  • Versatile connectivity including USB Wi-Fi and TF Card
  • Easy and well-documented assembly
  • Affordable entry point into CO2 lasers
  • LightBurn compatible out of the box
  • Robust metal construction
  • Included air assist and exhaust fan
CONS
  • No limit switches
  • Ineffective built-in smoke filter
  • Unreliable flame detector
  • Poorly implemented Wi-Fi hotspot
  • Slower cutting speeds than 20W model
  • Manual focus only, no autofocus
  • Open frame design with significant safety concerns
  • Unreliable onboard safety features (flame/motion detection)
  • Poor cable management
  • Firmware and UI can be buggy and unpolished
  • Air assist pump is an optional extra
  • Unreliable power supply causes restarts
  • Flame sensor prone to false alarms
  • Cutting thicker materials is slow with heavy charring
  • Requires mechanical tuning (belts, wheels) for best results
  • Laser lens is not user-replaceable risking costly module replacement
  • Potential for poor quality control on 20W module
  • Cable management is functional but untidy
  • Customer support can be unresponsive with technical issues
  • Open-frame design requires significant safety precautions
  • Small 8x12 inch work area
  • Requires manual mirror alignment and focusing
  • Inconsistent customer support
  • Included cooling and air assist are basic and often upgraded

AI Summary

Beta

Generating an in-depth overview…

GPT-5 mini is crunching the numbers for these lasers.

Related Content

Laser comparison FAQ

Quick answers to help you get the most out of the comparison tool.

How do I choose which lasers to compare?
💡
Start typing a model name in the search fields at the top of the page. You can mix brands, filter by usage type and switch lasers at any time without reloading the page.
Are the prices and specifications kept up to date?
💡
Yes. We refresh technical data from manufacturer documentation and track shop offers several times per day so you always see the latest pricing and availability.
Can I compare more than two machines at once?
💡
Absolutely. Use the “+ Add laser” button to add more columns, line up as many as five models side-by-side, and export the comparison or share the link with your team.